Eli is better than Brady

Eddie Silver · Joined: 07 Feb 2008 Posts: 6

More physical tools. Bigger, stronger, better arm.
Undefeated in SuperBowl play.

Eddie

Archived from group: alt>sports>football>pro>ny-giants

Joe · Joined: 03 Dec 2007 Posts: 8

On Feb 7, 8:59 am, Eddie Silver wrote:
> More physical tools. Bigger, stronger, better arm.
> Undefeated in SuperBowl play.
>
> Eddie

Stronger arm? did you see the 70 yard incompletion Brady threw at the
end of regulation? Manning has always had the best pedigree in
football history what was yet to be determined was if he had the
heart. That is undeniable now.

Eddie Silver · Joined: 07 Feb 2008 Posts: 6

Joe wrote:

> On Feb 7, 8:59 am, Eddie Silver wrote:
>
>>More physical tools. Bigger, stronger, better arm.
>>Undefeated in SuperBowl play.
>>
>>Eddie
>
>
> Stronger arm? did you see the 70 yard incompletion Brady threw at the
> end of regulation? Manning has always had the best pedigree in
> football history what was yet to be determined was if he had the
> heart. That is undeniable now.

Do you think there is a single Giant fan who would prefer Brady
over Eli?

richardhutnik · Joined: 21 Jan 2008 Posts: 27

On Feb 7, 7:36 pm, Eddie Silver wrote:
> Joe wrote:
> > On Feb 7, 8:59 am, Eddie Silver wrote:
>
> >>More physical tools. Bigger, stronger, better arm.
> >>Undefeated in SuperBowl play.
>
> >>Eddie
>
> > Stronger arm? did you see the 70 yard incompletion Brady threw at the
> > end of regulation? Manning has always had the best pedigree in
> > football history what was yet to be determined was if he had the
> > heart. That is undeniable now.
>
> Do you think there is a single Giant fan who would prefer Brady
> over Eli?

At this moment, NO Giant fan will admit to it. Before the post-season
I would say more Giant fans would take Brady over Eli.

- Rich

Fritz · Joined: 06 Aug 2007 Posts: 17

wrote in message @i7g2000prf.googlegroups.com...
> On Feb 7, 7:36 pm, Eddie Silver wrote:
>> Joe wrote:
>> > On Feb 7, 8:59 am, Eddie Silver wrote:
>>
>> >>More physical tools. Bigger, stronger, better arm.
>> >>Undefeated in SuperBowl play.
>>
>> >>Eddie
>>
>> > Stronger arm? did you see the 70 yard incompletion Brady threw at the
>> > end of regulation? Manning has always had the best pedigree in
>> > football history what was yet to be determined was if he had the
>> > heart. That is undeniable now.
>>
>> Do you think there is a single Giant fan who would prefer Brady
>> over Eli?
>
> At this moment, NO Giant fan will admit to it. Before the post-season
> I would say more Giant fans would take Brady over Eli.
>
I'm satisfied with Eli as our QB but I'd take Brady in a heartbeat.
Hopefully in 2 years I'll be on the other side of the fence.

number6 · Joined: 07 Aug 2007 Posts: 47

On Feb 8, 8:47 am, "Fritz" wrote:

>
> >> Do you think there is a single Giant fan who would prefer Brady
> >> over Eli?
>
> > At this moment, NO Giant fan will admit to it. Before the post-season
> > I would say more Giant fans would take Brady over Eli.
>
> I'm satisfied with Eli as our QB but I'd take Brady in a heartbeat.
> Hopefully in 2 years I'll be on the other side of the fence

I wouldn't ... not for ability or talent reasons ... you can argue
those all day ...but Eli not being the center of attention made the
team concept of the Giants work very well ... Brady is too much of a
personality for our team ... at this time anyway ...

warthog0 · Joined: 16 Oct 2007 Posts: 49

On Feb 8, 9:07 am, number6 wrote:
> On Feb 8, 8:47 am, "Fritz" wrote:
>
>
>
> > >> Do you think there is a single Giant fan who would prefer Brady
> > >> over Eli?
>
> > > At this moment, NO Giant fan will admit to it. Before the post-season
> > > I would say more Giant fans would take Brady over Eli.
>
> > I'm satisfied with Eli as our QB but I'd take Brady in a heartbeat.
> > Hopefully in 2 years I'll be on the other side of the fence
>
> I wouldn't ... not for ability or talent reasons ... you can argue
> those all day ...but Eli not being the center of attention made the
> team concept of the Giants work very well ... Brady is too much of a
> personality for our team ... at this time anyway ...

It may take a couple of years, but sooner or later Eli will be a
personality. It will be interesting to see how he handles the NY
paparazzi.

number6 · Joined: 07 Aug 2007 Posts: 47

On Feb 8, 9:31 am, warth...@gmail.com wrote:

>
> > I wouldn't ... not for ability or talent reasons ... you can argue
> > those all day ...but Eli not being the center of attention made the
> > team concept of the Giants work very well ... Brady is too much of a
> > personality for our team ... at this time anyway ...
>
> It may take a couple of years, but sooner or later Eli will be a
> personality. It will be interesting to see how he handles the NY
> paparazzi

He's had 4 years of hype here already and is still going to marry his
high school sweetheart ... Bodes well ...

Brady is not injured... He is just going over video footage of signs with the coaching staff... He needs to know when the Giants plan to blitz and so forth...

Tom Brady "Why do I have three super bowl rings and feel there is still more for me to do?" Brady tonight on minutes." Maybe he eventually wants to out couch Bill Bellichick, The Tuna, Vince Lom

Tom Brady..... how awesome is he? We knew he was a great qb, but over the last year or so he's morphed into probably the best qb in the he's became a fashion icon, a trendsetter, one of the coolest guys in america, etc..... I hope they go 19-0

BRADY! BRADY!!!! Anyone still want to keep Anderson?

Brady??? What the hell is wrong with Brady? He looks like he's in a daze. Just heaving the ball up for anybody. Big money get to him?